An AI-generated podcast companion to this article, produced with Google Gemini Notebook.
Something feels off, and nothing is flashing red
Most leaders in this position cannot point to a single event. Revenue is not collapsing. No major customer has walked away. The dashboards are mostly green, or at worst yellow. And yet there is a sense that the organization is becoming less relevant than it used to be. Customer conversations feel more transactional. Competitors you barely noticed a few years ago are gaining more and more visibility. Good people seem less energized about where the company is headed. You cannot name the problem, but you can feel it.
That feeling deserves to be taken seriously. Relevance rarely disappears all at once. It erodes while the organization keeps operating competently, which is exactly why it is so hard to see in the operating reports.
How it starts to show, and the instinctive response
Eventually the feeling finds numbers. Growth slows. Margins narrow as price pressure builds and customers ask for more concessions to say yes. New business takes longer and costs more to win.
The natural response is understandable. Work harder: push the sales team and stretch the targets. Spend less: freeze hiring, trim budgets, defer investments. And because the core offerings are no longer growing, start trying new things. A new product here, a new service there, a new audience somewhere else. Throw some spaghetti at the wall and see what sticks.
Each of those moves is reasonable on its own. Together they form a pattern. The experiments are scattered across different owners and different customers. All of them compete for the same shrinking pool of money and attention, so none is resourced well enough to succeed. When they underperform, the conclusion is that the market did not want them, when the more accurate conclusion is that they were never given a fair chance. Effort goes up, spending goes down, and relevance keeps eroding.
Step back from the engine
At some point, leaders have to look beyond how the engine is running. The engine is business operations: efficiency, throughput, cost, execution. Tuning it matters, but a well-tuned engine alone cannot win a race. In this analogy, “winning a race” means being the one customers choose, out of all the alternatives available to them, to meet a defined need with their limited attention, time, and money. In other words, a well-running engine matters, but it has to power the right vehicle (products and services) and be steered toward the right destination (customer segments). Without this focus, a fine-tuned engine will only help an organization increase the speed and decrease the cost of getting to the wrong location.
Three questions follow:
- Are we headed toward a group of customers who have a compelling need that we are able to meet?
- Is our vehicle the best one for that journey, or was it built for terrain that has since changed?
- Is that vehicle good enough to beat the competitors heading for the same customers?
These are not operating questions. Better execution will not answer them, and pushing the operations team harder will not either. They belong to the CEO, the board, or the owners. The rest of this article lays out one way to answer them, built around an idea called a winning proposition.
Why traditional strategic planning rarely answers these questions
Most organizations already run a strategic planning process, so you might expect it to surface exactly this kind of assessment. Usually it does not. Four features recur, and each pushes the output toward an operating plan.
- It starts from the present and extrapolates. Last year's results and last year's structure become the baseline. The plan adds a growth target and asks each function how it will contribute. That produces function-level goals, which is operational planning by another name.
- It runs on the budget calendar. The schedule is set by what can be funded and tracked within a fiscal year, so questions that take longer to answer get dropped.
- It aims for consensus. Leaders from each area bring their priorities, and the plan accommodates all of them. Accommodation feels collaborative. It is also the fastest way to guarantee that nothing receives concentrated resources.
- It measures activity. Milestones and completion rates are easy to track. Whether the organization is becoming more compelling to a chosen customer is harder to measure, so it is rarely asked.
The common tools reinforce the pattern. A SWOT analysis lists considerations without forcing a choice among them. A mission and vision statement describes aspiration without naming an alternative to beat. Growth targets describe an outcome without explaining what customers need or why they would choose you to deliver it.
The result is a document that looks strategic and functions operationally. It tells everyone what to do. It does not say where the organization is going, what vehicle will get it there, or what to stop doing along the way.
The alternative: identify and select a winning proposition
The assessment that matters starts with a different question: how will we win, against real alternatives, by meeting a defined need for a specific group of paying customers? The answer is what Willie Pietersen of Columbia Business School calls a “winning proposition.”
This is easy to confuse with the “value proposition” most organizations already have. A value proposition describes the value you create, and it is insufficient. That's because value is relative. Even if you provide customers with a five-to-one return on investment, that will not win against a competitor who provides a ten-to-one return.
A winning proposition, on the other hand, describes the margin of difference between the value you create and the value your closest alternative creates, stated precisely enough that a customer has a compelling reason to choose you. It also has to explain how that advantage turns into superior financial returns. For a leader worried about growth and margins, that second half is the point.
I make the concept usable with three parts.
| Part | The question it answers | In the vehicle metaphor |
|---|---|---|
| Who | Which paying customers have we chosen to serve above all others? | The destination |
| What | Which products and services meet a defined need for them? | The vehicle |
| How | What strategic moat keeps competitors from simply following? | What makes the vehicle hard to copy |
A winning proposition lives where all three overlap. Hamilton Helmer's seven powers (scale economies, network economies, counter-positioning, switching costs, branding, cornered resource, and process power) give a way to test the How. An approach that a competitor can replicate within a year will not turn growth and margins around.
This is also where deliberate exploration differs from throwing spaghetti. Spaghetti tries new Whats at random, usually with the same Who and the same How. Strategic exploration tests whole combinations of Who, What, and How against each other before committing real resources, and keeps the one that survives. Warby Parker did not start by deciding to sell inexpensive glasses. It tested combinations of customer, offering, and delivery model until one held up.
Once a winning proposition is selected, it becomes the organizing principle for the choices that actually determine whether the organization can win. People: the knowledge, skills, and attitudes you hire and develop. Structures: how resources are allocated, performance is tracked, and personnel are managed. Processes: the practices that let those people, working inside those structures, deliver the proposition consistently.
Amazon's winning proposition of a frictionless, low-cost, fast, and reliable customer experience shows up in how it hires for customer obsession, organizes into small autonomous teams, and runs on relentless automation and experimentation. The proposition did not just describe the strategy. It told the organization which people, structures, and processes it needed and which it did not.
What changes when strategy leads
Putting the winning proposition first changes the plan in three practical ways.
The strategic plan gets short. It states the chosen Who, What, and How, the evidence and assumptions behind them, and the handful of strategic priorities needed to close the gap between where the organization stands and where the proposition requires it to be. Strategic planning is the process of arriving at that choice. The strategic plan is the record of it. Neither is a list of activities.
The operating plan becomes a consequence. Operational and business planning stays essential. It turns priorities into goals, staffing, timelines, and budgets. But each goal must now trace to a part of the Who, What, or How, and goals that cannot are candidates to defer, downsize, delegate, or delete. Scarce resources then concentrate on the few efforts that strengthen the proposition, which is the opposite of spreading a shrinking base across everything.
The “no” list becomes explicit. Porter's point that the essence of strategy is choosing what not to do is not a slogan. Ryanair flies one aircraft type, uses secondary airports, and charges extra for what other airlines include. Each limit is a deliberate trade-off that makes its advantage possible. An organization that cannot name its own limits has not made a strategic choice yet.
There is a reasonable objection. Leaders facing declining margins often cannot afford a long strategic exercise, and some will say the first move should be to stabilize costs and fix operations. That is sometimes right, particularly in a genuine cash emergency. The risk is that stabilization becomes the plan. Costs get cut with no principle for protecting what customers value, and the organization ends up leaner but no more relevant. The better sequence is to do the minimum needed to stay solvent while making the strategic choice quickly, then let that choice guide where to invest and where to cut.
A second objection is that a chosen strategy may be wrong. It may be. Treat the winning proposition as a testable hypothesis, name the assumptions it depends on, and let early operational results show whether they hold. That keeps strategy first without making it rigid.
If the proposition is sound, it also gives a reasoned basis for expecting better economics. Customers who have a compelling reason to choose you are less likely to need discounts to do so, and a moat built on real powers is harder for competitors to undercut. The proposition does not guarantee the result. It makes the result something you can plan for.
Questions a CEO, board member, or owner can ask management
You do not need to run the planning process yourself to tell whether it produced a strategy. These questions work in a single meeting.
- Who is the specific customer we are choosing to win, and who are we choosing not to serve?
- What would that customer do if we did not exist, and why do we beat that alternative?
- Which part of how we deliver would a competitor struggle to copy in the next two years?
- Which initiatives on the plan strengthen that advantage, and which are here because they were already here?
- If our budget fell by ten percent tomorrow, what would we protect first, and what principle tells us?
- What have we decided to stop doing in order to fund the things that matter?
Listen to the quality of the answers more than the content. If the answers are specific and consistent across the leadership team, a strategy exists. If they vary by executive, or arrive as lists of programs, the organization has an operating plan and is calling it a strategy.
Where this leaves the leader
Declining growth and margins are usually described as execution problems because execution is what you can see. The deeper question is whether the organization has made a choice about who it serves and how it wins that is sharp enough to organize everything else. When it has, scarce resources have somewhere to go, and “no” has a reason behind it. When it has not, even excellent execution is spread too thin to matter.
The Point
Strategy and operations both have to be done well. The order is what most organizations get wrong.
Sources and related reading
- Willie Pietersen, Strategic Learning: How to Be Smarter Than Your Competition and Turn Key Insights into Competitive Advantage. Origin of the winning proposition concept. The Who, What, How structure is my own formulation.
- Hamilton Helmer, 7 Powers, and Michael Porter's writing on strategic trade-offs.
- Signal Over Noise, on line of sight and the five Ds.
- The Plan Was Never the Point, on treating plans as hypotheses to test.
- From “AI Everywhere” to Discovery-Driven Strategy, on turning broad mandates into focused, testable bets.